The experts at Scrambling Egg have answered the challenge. We’ve rolled up our sleeves and sharpened our pencils. We’ve dug into the history books and dusted off the spreadsheets. If that is even possible.
We now have our Top 100 Quarterbacks of All-Time. In this list we have our magnum opus. This is the definitive list of the best passers, best game managers, most effective play callers.
Our Top 100 list is not based on whimsy. This is scientific. Here’s how we ranked the quarterbacks:
- +10 for each Super Bowl or NFL Championship won
- +6 for each Super Bowl loss
- +1 for every 4,000 yards passing
- +1 for every 25 TD passes
- -1 for every 10 interceptions thrown
- +3 for every percentage point ABOVE 45% in completion percentage
- +2 for each Pro Bowl selection
- +2 for each NFL All-Pro selection
The table lists 100 quarterbacks, going as far back as Sammy Baugh, all the way up to current stars Josh Allen and Joe Burrow, and more.
Our list includes this star-studded Top 5:
- Tom Brady
- Patrick Mahomes
- Peyton Manning
- Aaron Rodgers
- Drew Brees
Which quarterback is ranked too low or too high? What arguments do you have with our rankings? Let us know in the comments below.
